The following is taken from James E. Snapp’s post: James White and the NA/UBS Compilation.
“So do not throw away your confidence, which has a great reward.” – Hebrews 10:35Do not therefore lose your confidence which hath a great reward. (EHV)
When one version of the New Testament has a verse, and another version does not have it, that’s something worth looking into. When one version of the New Testament has 40 verses that another version doesn’t have, that’s definitely something worth looking into.
Textual criticism involves the investigation of those differences, and more: not only are there some differences in manuscripts that involve the inclusion or non-inclusion of entire verses, but also hundreds of differences in manuscripts that involve important phrases and words. (There are hundreds of thousands of trivial differences in the manuscripts, involving word-order and spelling, but the ones that involve non-synonymous differences in the wording of the text are the ones that tend to get the most attention.)
How can ordinary Christians confidently maintain confidence that the New Testament they hold in their hands conveys the same authoritative message that was conveyed by the original documents of the New Testament books? To an extent, this is something one takes on faith, since there is no way to scientifically prove that the reconstructed archetype of the text of all witnesses is the same as the text of the autographs.
But that does not mean that one’s position about specific readings should be selected at random, rather than via careful consideration of the evidence.
When that careful consideration has been made, though, what should one do with one’s conclusions? You might think that after scribal corruptions have been filtered out via text-critical analysis, the obvious thing for Christians to do would be to treat the reconstructed text as the Word of God, a text uniquely imbued with divine authority. However, if one is to do something with one’s conclusions, one must first have conclusions – and here we have a problem, because there is no sign of the Nestle-Aland and UBS compilations of the Greek New Testament (both of which present the same text) ever being more than provisional and tentative.
As the Introduction to the 27th edition of the Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece states:
“It should naturally be understood that this text is a working text (in the sense of the century-long Nestle tradition): it is not to be considered as definitive.”
Anyone who wants a definitive text of the New Testament should abandon all hope of such a thing emerging from the team of scholars who produce the Nestle-Aland and UBS compilations.
The built-in instability of the NA/UBS compilation is understandable – nobody wants to say, “We are resolved to ignore any new evidence that may be discovered in the future” – but it is also somewhat problematic: it has caused some apologists, such as James White, to effectively nullify the authority of some parts of the New Testament. Christians are being told that they should not regard a particular verse, or a particular phrase, or a particular word, as authoritative, on the grounds that the compilers of the NA/UBS compilation have declared it questionable.
Even if a reading is included in the text today, the compilers might change their minds about it tomorrow, and therefore, it has been proposed, readers should not put much weight on such readings.
Instead of producing a compilation in which every textual contest is won, the NA/UBS compilers often advise readers to treat a contested passage as if its original contents cannot be known – in which case, none of the rival readings can be safely treated as Scripture.
For example, James White said this regarding Luke 23:34a (“Then Jesus said, ‘Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.”):
“In Luke 23:34And Jesus said: Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do. But they, dividing his garments, cast lots., there is a major textual variant. And, as a result, you should be very careful about making large theological points based upon what is truly a highly questionable text.”
In another video, White stated the following, referring again to Luke 23:34a:
“When you have a serious textual variant, you should not, in an apologetic context, place a tremendous amount of theological weight upon a text that could be properly and fairly questioned as to its specific reading. And so, I don’t think that you should build a theology based upon this text.”
Speaking for myself, I think the original text of the New Testament ought to be the basis for Christian theology, whether it was perfectly perpetuated by scribes or not.
While there are textual contests which are extremely close (close enough to justify a footnote providing the alternative reading), the number of such cases is not as high as the compilers of the NA/UBS text make it out to be.
There is a clear danger and weakness in the approach being advocated by White and by whoever else proposes that “We shouldn’t build theology upon a disputed text”: the danger of relegating parts of genuine Scripture to a non-authoritative status merely because they have been questioned by textual critics. Is White aware of how much of the New Testament has been questioned by textual critics? Here are some passages in the Gospels which, if White’s approach were used consistently, would go into a “Do Not Use for Theological Purposes” category, and their subjects:
Mt. 1:7-8And Solomon begot Roboam. And Roboam begot Abia. And Abia begot Asa. (Was Jesus descended from Asaph and Amos? Or, were the names of Asa and Amon spelled the same as the names of Asaph and Amos?)
Mt. 1:16And Jacob begot Joseph the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus, who is called Christ. (Was Joseph the father of Jesus?)
Mt. 1:18Now the generation of Christ was in this wise. When as his mother Mary was espoused to Joseph, before they came together, she was found with child, of the Holy Ghost. (Was Jesus already Christ when he was born?)
Mt. 1:25And he knew her not, till she brought forth her first born son: and he called his name Jesus. (Did Mary have other children besides Jesus?)
Mt. 9:34But the Pharisees said, By the prince of devils he casteth out devils. (Did Pharisees accuse Jesus of casting out demons by the ruler of the demons?)
Mt. 12:47And one said unto him: Behold thy mother and thy brethren stand without, seeking thee. (Did someone tell Jesus His mother and brothers were outside?)
Mt. 13:35That it might be fulfilled which was spoken by the prophet, saying: I will open my mouth in parables, I will utter things hidden from the foundation of the world. (Did Matthew say that Isaiah wrote Psalm 72, which is ascribed to Asaph?) (Or to put it another way: Did Matthew err?)
Mt. 16:2-3But he answered and said to them: When it is evening, you say, It will be fair weather, for the sky is red. (Did Jesus say this?)
Mt. 17:21And when they abode together in Galilee, Jesus said to them: The Son of man shall be betrayed into the hands of men: (Did Jesus say that prayer and fasting were needed prior to casting out a particular kind of demon?)
Mt. 18:11For the Son of man is come to save that which was lost. (Why did Jesus come?)
Mt. 18:15But if thy brother shall offend against thee, go, and rebuke him between thee and him alone. If he shall hear thee, thou shalt gain thy brother. (Is the subject about any sin, or about when one is personally wronged?)
Mt. 19:9And I say to you, that whosoever shall put away his wife, except it be for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth adultery: and he that shall marry her that is put away, committeth adultery. (Is remarriage permitted after divorce?)
Mt. 21:31Which of the two did the father's will? They say to him: The first. Jesus saith to them: Amen I say to you that the publicans and the harlots shall go into the kingdom of God before you. (What did the crowd say to Jesus?)
Mt. 21:44And whosoever shall fall on this stone shall be broken: but on whomsoever it shall fall, it shall grind him to powder. (Is this verse original?)
Mt. 23:14Woe to you scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you devour the houses of widows, praying long prayers. For this you shall receive the greater judgment. (Is this verse original?)
Mt. 26:28For this is my blood of the new testament, which shall be shed for many unto remission of sins. (Did Jesus say “new covenant” or just “covenant”?)
Mt. 27:16And he had then a notorious prisoner that was called Barabbas. (Was Barabbas also named Jesus?)
Mt. 27:35And after they had crucified him, they divided his garments, casting lots; that it might be fulfilled which was spoken by the prophet, saying: They divided my garments among them; and upon my vesture they cast lots.b (Is this verse original?)
Mt. 27:49And the others said: Let be. Let us see whether Elias will come to deliver him. (Was Jesus pierced with a spear before He died?) (Or to put it another way: Do Matthew and John contradict each other?)
Mt. 28:19Going therefore, teach ye all nations: baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost. (Did Jesus advocate baptism “in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit”?)
Mk. 1:1-3The beginning of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. (Are these verses original?)
Mk. 1:1The beginning of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. (Did Mark consider Jesus to be inherently the Son of God?)
Mk. 1:2As it is written in Isaias the prophet: Behold I send my angel before thy face, who shall prepare the way before thee. (Did Mark blend together two passages, one from Isaiah and one from Malachi, and introduce them as having been written by Isaiah?)
Mk. 1:40And there came a leper to him, beseeching him and kneeling down, said to him: If thou wilt thou canst make me clean. (Did the man with leprosy kneel to Jesus?)
Mk. 1:41And Jesus, having compassion on him, stretched forth his hand and touching him saith to him: I will. Be thou made clean. (When requested to heal the leper, was Jesus angry, or was He filled with compassion?)
Mk. 6:22And when the daughter of the same Herodias had come in, and had danced, and pleased Herod, and them that were at table with him, the king said to the damsel: Ask of me what thou wilt, and I will give it thee. (Was the dancer at Herod’s court the daughter of Herodias, or the daughter of Herod?)
Mk. 7:4And when they come from the market, unless they be washed, they eat not: and many other things there are that have been delivered to them to observe, the washings of cups and of pots and of brazen vessels and of beds. (Did Mark refer here to immersion, or to pouring?)
Mk. 7:16If any man have ears to hear, let him hear. (Is this verse original?)
Mk. 7:19Because it entereth not into his heart but goeth into his belly and goeth out into the privy, purging all meats? (Did Jesus declare all foods to be fit to eat, or did He describe what happens to food after digestion?)
Mk. 8:38For he that shall be ashamed of me and of my words, in this adulterous and sinful generation: the Son of man also will be ashamed of him, when he shall come in the glory of his Father with the holy angels. (Did Jesus refer to His words, or to His followers?)
Mk. 9:29And departing from thence, they passed through Galilee: and he would not that any man should know it. (Did Jesus say that fasting was needed prior to casting out a particular kind of demon?)
Mk. 9:44And if thy foot scandalize thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter lame into life everlasting than having two feet to be cast into the hell of unquenchable fire: and 9:46 (Did Jesus emphasize the eternal nature of suffering in hell?)
Mk. 10:24And the disciples were astonished at his words. But Jesus again answering, saith to them: Children, how hard is it for them that trust in riches to enter into the kingdom of God? (Did Jesus say that it is hard to enter into the kingdom of God, or that it is hard for those who trust in riches to enter the kingdom of God?)
Mk. 11:26But if you will not forgive, neither will your father that is in heaven forgive you your sins. (Is it necessary to forgive those who have sinned against us?)
Mk. 13:14And when you shall see the abomination of desolation, standing where it ought not (he that readeth let him understand): then let them that are in Judea flee unto the mountains. (Did Jesus affirm that Daniel was a historical character?)
Mk. 14:24And he said to them: This is my blood of the new testament, which shall be shed for many. (Did Jesus say “new covenant” or just “covenant”?)
Mk. 15:28And the scripture was fulfilled, which saith: And with the wicked he was reputed. (Is this verse original?)
Mk. 16:9-20 (Are these 12 verses, including their record of Jesus’ post-resurrection appearances, and His command to go into all the world and preach the gospel, original?)
Lk. 1:46And Mary said: My soul doth magnify the Lord. (Was it Mary, or Elizabeth, who sang the Magnificat?)
Lk. 2:14Glory to God in the highest: and on earth peace to men of good will. (Did the angels say “Peace on earth, goodwill to men,” or “Peace on earth upon those favored by God”?)
Lk. 3:22And the Holy Ghost descended in a bodily shape, as a dove, upon him. And a voice came from heaven: Thou art my beloved Son. In thee I am well pleased. (Did Luke describe the Father’s voice as if Jesus had become His Son at His baptism?)
Lk. 4:44And he was preaching in the synagogues of Galilee. (Was Jesus preaching in the synagogues in Galilee, or in the synagogues of Judea?)
Lk. 5:39And no man drinking old hath presently a mind to new: for he saith: The old is better. (Is this verse original?)
Lk. 6:48He is like to a man building a house, who digged deep and laid the foundation upon a rock. And when a flood came, the stream beat vehemently upon that house: and it could not shake it: for it was founded on a rock. (Is the final phrase in this verse original?)
Lk. 8:26And they sailed to the country of the Gerasens, which is over against Galilee. (To what region did Jesus and His disciples go?)
Lk. 8:43And there was a certain woman having an issue of blood twelve years, who had bestowed all her substance on physicians and could not be healed by any. (Is part of this verse a scribal corruption?)
Lk. 9:26For he that shall be ashamed of me and of my words, of him the Son of man shall be ashamed, when he shall come in his majesty and that of his Father and of the holy angels. (Did Jesus refer to His words, or to His followers?)
Lk. 10:1And after these things, the Lord appointed also other seventy-two. And he sent them two and two before his face into every city and place whither he himself was to come. and 10:17 (Did Jesus send 70 individuals, or 72?)
Lk. 10:42But one thing is necessary. Mary hath chosen the best part, which shall not be taken away from her. (What did Jesus say to Martha?)
Lk. 11:13If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father from heaven give the good Spirit to them that ask him? (Did Jesus refer to gifts in general, or to the gift of the Holy Spirit?)
Lk. 11:42But woe to you, Pharisees, because you tithe mint and rue and every herb and pass over judgment and the charity of God. Now these things you ought to have done, and not to leave the other undone. (Did Jesus affirm the regulations of the Law of Moses?)
Lk. 14:5And answering them, he said: Which of you shall have an ass or an ox fall into a pit and will not immediately draw him out, on the sabbath day? (Did Jesus refer to a donkey, or to a son, or to a sheep?)
Lk. 17:36They answering, say to him: Where, Lord? (Did Jesus emphasize that one shall be taken, and another shall be left?)
Lk. 18:11The Pharisee standing, prayed thus with himself: O God, I give thee thanks that I am not as the rest of men, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, as also is this publican. (Was the Pharisee praying “with himself”?)
Lk. 18:24And Jesus seeing him become sorrowful, said: How hardly shall they that have riches enter into the kingdom of God (Was Jesus very sorrowful when the rich young ruler did not accept His offer?)
Lk. 19:25And they said to him: Lord, he hath ten pounds. (Is this verse original?)
Lk. 22:43-44And there appeared to him an angel from heaven, strengthening him. And being in an agony, he prayed the longer. (Did Jesus’ body produce drops of sweat like blood? And did an angel appear to Him in Gethsemane, strengthening Him?)
Lk. 22:62And Peter going out, wept bitterly. (After denying Jesus three times, did Peter depart and weep bitterly?)
Lk. 23:17Now of necessity he was to release unto them one upon the feast day. (Is this verse original?)
Lk. 23:34And Jesus said: Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do. But they, dividing his garments, cast lots.a (Did Jesus ask the Father to forgive those who were responsible for crucifying Him?)
Lk. 24:3And going in, they found not the body of the Lord Jesus. (Did Luke specify that the women visiting the tomb did not find the body “of the Lord Jesus”?)
Lk. 24:6He is not here, but is risen. Remember how he spoke unto you, when he was yet in Galilee, (Did Luke state that the men said to the women at the tomb, “He is not here, but is risen”?)
Lk. 24:12But Peter rising up, ran to the sepulchre and, stooping down, he saw the linen cloths laid by themselves: and went away wondering in himself at that which was come to pass. (Did Luke write this verse, which reports that Peter ran to the tomb and saw the linen cloths?)
Lk. 24:36Now, whilst they were speaking these things, Jesus stood in the midst of them and saith to them: Peace be to you. It is I: Fear not. (Did Jesus greet His disciples by saying “Peace unto you”?)
Lk. 24:40And when he had said this, he shewed them his hands and feet. (Did Jesus show His disciples His hands and His feet?)
Lk. 24:42And they offered him a piece of a broiled fish and a honeycomb. (Was Jesus given a piece of honeycomb to eat, as well as fish?)
Lk. 24:51And it came to pass, whilst he blessed them, he departed from them and was carried up to heaven. (Did Luke say specifically that Jesus “was carried up into heaven”?)
Jn. 1:18No man hath seen God at any time: the only begotten Son who is in the Bosom of the Father, he hath declared him. (Did John call Jesus “only begotten God” or “the only begotten Son”?)
Jn. 1:34And I saw: and I gave testimony that this is the Son of God. (Did John the Baptist affirm that Jesus was the Son of God, or that Jesus was the chosen one of God?)
Jn. 3:13And no man hath ascended into heaven, but he that descended from heaven, the Son of man who is in heaven. (Did the verse originally end with the phrase, “the Son of Man who is in heaven”?)
Jn. 4:9Then that Samaritan woman saith to him: How dost thou, being a Jew; ask of me to drink, who am a Samaritan woman? For the Jews do not communicate with the Samaritans. (Did the verse originally end with the phrase, “For Jews have no dealings with Samaritans”?)
Jn. 5:3-4In these lay a great multitude of sick, of blind, of lame, of withered: waiting for the moving of the water. (Did John write an explanation of why sick and infirm people were gathered at the pool called Bethesda?)
Jn. 6:23But other ships came in from Tiberias, nigh unto the place where they had eaten the bread, the Lord giving thanks. (Did John write the final phrase of this verse, mentioning that the Lord gave thanks for the bread?)
Jn. 6:36But I said unto you that you also have seen me, and you believe not. (Did Jesus say that whoever comes to Him will never hunger and that whoever believes in Him will never thirst?)
Jn. 6:47Amen, amen, I say unto you: He that believeth in me hath everlasting life. (Did Jesus say that whoever believes on Him has eternal life?”)
Jn. 7:8Go you up to this festival day: but I go not up to this festival day, because my time is not accomplished. (Did Jesus say He was not going to the feast, or that He was not yet going?)
Jn. 7:39Now this he said of the Spirit which they should receive who believed in him: for as yet the Spirit was not given, because Jesus was not yet glorified. (Did John say that the Holy Spirit was not yet given?)
Jn. 7:53-8:11 (Are these 12 verses – the story about the adulteress – original?)
Jn. 8:59They took up stones therefore to cast at him. But Jesus hid himself and went out of the temple. (Did Jesus go through the midst of the people, and so pass by?)
Jn. 9:38-39And he said: I believe, Lord. And falling down, he adored him. (Did the man who had received his sight say, “Lord, I believe,” and worship Jesus?)
Jn. 10:8All others, as many as have come, are thieves and robbers: and the sheep heard them not. (Did Jesus say that all who came before Him are thieves and robbers?)
Jn. 12:8For the poor you have always with you: but me you have not always. (Is this verse original?)
Jn. 12:32And I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all things to myself. (Did Jesus say that He would draw all people to Himself, or that He would draw everything to Himself?)
Jn. 14:14If you shall ask me any thing in my name, that I will do. (Is this verse original, and if it is original, does it depict Jesus referring to prayers offered to Him?)
Jn. 17:11And now I am not in the world, and these are in the world, and I come to thee. Holy Father, keep them in thy name whom thou hast given me: that they may be one, as we also are. (Did Jesus refer to the elect – “those whom You have given Me” – in this verse?)
Jn. 19:29Now there was a vessel set there, full of vinegar. And they, putting a sponge full of vinegar about hyssop, put it to his mouth. (Was a hyssop-branch, or a javelin, used to offer wine to Jesus?)
Jn. 20:31But these are written, that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God: and that believing, you may have life in his name. (Did the Gospel of John originally end at the end of 20:31?
If I were to delve into the rest of the New Testament, more such passages could be listed, such as Acts 20:28Take heed to yourselves and to the whole flock, wherein the Holy Ghost hath placed you bishops, to rule the Church of God which he hath purchased with his own blood. (did God purchase the church with His own blood?), First Corinthians 14:34-35Let women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted them to speak but to be subject, as also the law saith. (Did Paul say that women are to be silent in the churches and are not permitted to speak?), Galatians 2:20And I live, now not I: but Christ liveth in me. And that I live now in the flesh: I live in the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and delivered himself for me. (Did Paul say that he lived by faith in the Son of God?), Galatians 4:25For Sina is a mountain in Arabia, which hath affinity to that Jerusalem which now is: and is in bondage with her children. (Is the first part of the verse a scribal corruption?), First Timothy 3:16And evidently great is the mystery of godliness, which was manifested in the flesh, was justified in the spirit, appeared unto angels, hath been preached unto the Gentiles, is believed in the world, is taken up in glory. (Did Paul state that in Jesus, God was manifest in the flesh?), Hebrews 2:9But we see Jesus, who was made a little lower than the angels, for the suffering of death, crowned with glory and honour: that, through the grace of God he might taste death for all. (Did Jesus taste death “apart from God”?), and Revelation 13:18Here is wisdom. He that hath understanding, let him count the number of the beast. For it is the number of a man: and the number of him is six hundred sixty-six. (Is the number of the beast 616 or 666?).
Does anyone think that this is how the Holy Spirit wanted these passages to be treated when He inspired the writers of the New Testament? Christians confidently believe (or ought to confidently believe) that all Scripture is profitable for doctrine – but it can’t be profitable for doctrine if its authority is not recognized.
Few are moved by the declaration, “Thus saith the Lord, maybe.”
An objection might be raised:
“But it is not as if those readings have been arbitrarily declared dubious; the passages you listed have been properly and fairly questioned.”
Who says? Does anyone have transcripts of the conversations that led the NA/UBS compilers to almost habitually reject the reading of the vast majority of Greek manuscripts where it diverges from the Alexandrian Text (usually in the Gospels, the Byzantine Text is favored by a majority of over 85% of the Greek manuscripts, frequently over 95%, and sometimes over 99.5%), and to regularly prefer the readings of Codex Vaticanus even where it stands in a very small minority and disagrees with the oldest evidence?
James White does not think the BA/UBS compilers were correct when they introduced a conjectural emendation (that is, a reading with no Greek manuscript support) into the text of Second Peter 3:10But the day of the Lord shall come as a thief, in which the heavens shall pass away with great violence and the elements shall be melted with heat and the earth and the works which are in it shall be burnt up.. But clearly the previously accepted reading of Second Peter 3:10But the day of the Lord shall come as a thief, in which the heavens shall pass away with great violence and the elements shall be melted with heat and the earth and the works which are in it shall be burnt up. is now disputed; White, if he consistently refrains from using disputed passages for theological purposes, will stop using it. Does anyone not see a problem here? Almost anything – the disagreement of a single Greek manuscript, or the opacity of a reading to the compilers – has been used to justify disputing readings that are supported by evidence that is early and abundant and widespread.
The NA/UBS compilation is unstable and it is very likely to become more unstable. And if anyone optimistically imagines that only readings that the UBS compilation-committee previously assigned a “D” rating are unstable, think again: in the 28th edition, the editors reversed what had been assigned an “A” rating in Second Peter 2:18For, speaking proud words of vanity, they allure by the desires of fleshly riotousness those who for a little while escape, such as converse in error:.
That is, it is not only readings which the compilers regard with “a very high degree of doubt” which are now considered questionable; readings which in previous editions of the NA/UBS compilation were considered “virtually certain” are also vulnerable to change.
It is not my intention here to defend every one of the inspired readings which James White regards as unsafe to use as Scripture. I merely observe that the approach he currently endorses – in which all that is needed to justify voiding the authority of a passage is for some textual critics to declare that after properly and fairly exploring the issue, their verdict is a shrug – is bound to introduce more and more instability into the text, and to consequently encourage readers to lose confidence in more and more passages – not because the passages have been shown to be non-original, but merely because they have been disputed.
This is not as large a problem as the Nestle-Aland compilation’s rejection of many original readings. But it is a problem.