The following is taken from The Moody Handbook of Messianic Prophecies: Studies and Expositions of the Messiah in the Old Testament, eds. Michael Rydelnik & Edwin Blum, published by Moody Publishers, Chicago, IL 2019, pp. 739-746. All emphasis will be mine.
Proverbs 8
The Messiah: Personification of Divine Wisdom
SETH D. POSTELL
Proverbs 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. has long been regarded as an important passage for the Christology of the Church. For many throughout Church history, this passage referred to the preincarnate Son of God, Divine Wisdom, who is the Father’s eternal delight and through whom all things were created.
In modern times, however, the majority of Christian commentators have rejected the Christological interpretation. Bruce Waltke, in his recent commentary on Proverbs, states emphatically,
“The notion that Wisdom is eternally being begotten is based on Christian dogma, not exegesis…. Augustine, Calvin, et al. erred in that they wrongly interpreted Wisdom as a hypostasis of God that they equated with Jesus Christ and not as a personification of the sage’s wisdom.”1
The thesis of this article is that Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. does in fact refer to God’s eternal Son, through whom the universe was created. The goal of this exposition is to invite God’s people to emulate the Father by joining Him in the delight of His Son.
The first section of this article will examine how Prv 8 was interpreted in early Jewish and Christian sources. The second section will look at the place of Proverbs within the Hebrew canon and also set the context of chap. 8 within the book itself. There it will be argued that the messianic interpretation is substantiated by the innertextual testimony of Prv 30:4-6Who hath ascended up into heaven, and descended? who hath held the wind in his hands? who hath bound up the waters together as in a garment? who hath raised up all the borders of the earth? what is his name, and what is the name of his…. The third section will offer an exposition of the passage.
THE PROMINENCE OF PROVERBS 8:22-31 IN THE HISTORY OF INTERPRETATION
The prominence of Prv 8 in the effective history of interpretation, both Jewish and Christian, is amazing. Before looking at how this passage influenced the Targums and Rashi in their interpretation of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth., it is crucial to recognize that Prv 8 has not only been interpreted, it is an interpretation.
There is an obvious correlation between this portion of Scripture and the early chapters of Genesis. Most striking of all is the appearance of “beginning” (v. 22; reshit) in the opening colon of this poem. In Prv 8:22The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning., the “beginning” chronologically precedes “the beginning” of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.. In other words, if Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. is understood temporally (“In the beginning”) then Prv 8:22The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. personifies this as One who was with God before the beginning.2 The “beginning” One is with God before the works of old (8:22b), before the depths (8:24), before the heavens were fashioned (8:27-28), before creation.
Proverbs 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. has many other words besides “beginning” (reshit) in common with the early chapters of Genesis. 3 These lexical similarities indicate that Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. should be understood as a poetic (and theological) interpretation of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.. It is clear from the Aramaic Targums and Rashi that this interpretation was taken seriously. In fact, Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. proved to be an interpretation so powerful that subsequent interpreters did not read Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. apart from the interpretation offered in Prv 8.
The Fragmentary Targum (FT) likely preserves a pre-Christian interpretation of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth., and reflects an understanding of the creation account informed by Prv 8. The FT uses the single word reshit in Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. twice, once temporally and the second nominally.
Thus, the word reshit is first included to mean “in the beginning.” Then, with its intertextual connotation connecting it to Prv 8, it is identified as the personification of wisdom. Therefore, the FT reads,
“In the beginning (reshit) with wisdom (reshit = chochmah) God created the heavens and the earth.”4
This interpretation of the creation account has been noticeably influenced by the wisdom literature in the OT.5 There are many clues within the opening and closing chapters of the Pentateuch to suggest that such a reading is also consistent with the final composition of the Pentateuch itself.6
More remarkable than the FT is the famous Targum Neophyti (TN). This Targum, even more expansive than the FT, includes yet a third interpretation of reshit: “In the beginning, with wisdom, the Son of the LORD7 created the heavens and the earth.”8 To many modern readers, this extraordinary pre-Christian interpretation appears fanciful. Several lines of evidence, however, suggest that this Targum offers an interpretation that is attentive to the details of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. within the final composition of the Pentateuch and also identical to the interpretation of the creation account provided by the book of Proverbs.
There are at least four textual factors that support TN interpretation of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.: (1) the poetic and literary qualities of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. lend themselves to a poetic interpretation;9 (2) rishonah, (“at first”) rather than reshit (“beginning”) is the proper Hebrew word for initiating temporal sequence in Hebrew;10 (3) the appearance of reshit in the poetic eschatological seams of the Pentateuch (Gn 49:3Ruben, my firstborn, thou art my strength, and the beginning of my sorrow; excelling in gifts, greater in command.; Nm 24:20And when he saw Amalec, he took up his parable, and said: Amalec the beginning of nations, whose latter ends shall be destroyed.; Dt 33:21And he saw his pre-eminence, that in his portion the teacher was laid up: who was with the princes of the people, and did the justices of the Lord, and his judgment with Israel.); and finally, (4) the interpretation of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. offered by the book of Proverbs.
Rashi, following in the tradition of the Targums, refers to Prv 8:22The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. in his interpretation of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.. He writes,
“For the sake of the Torah [by the Torah] God created the heavens and the earth.”11
Proverbs 8 left an indelible mark on the Jewish interpretation of the creation account. Proverbs 8 also proved to be an important passage for the Christology of the early Church fathers. Among the Church fathers who understood Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. as a reference to the Son of God are Justin Martyr, Athenagoras, Tertullian, Origen, Eusebius of Caesarea, Athanasius, Hilary of Poitiers, and Augustine.12 Proverbs 8, however, was also wielded as a textual weapon by the Arian heretics, largely because of the Septuagint’s rendering of the Hebrew kanah (“possess,” “create,” or “beget”) as ktizo (“create”). The Arians used this verse to argue that the Son of God was created (see below for the response to this exegetical claim).13
… The book of Proverbs, throughout, praises wisdom and its importance in the horizontal and vertical directions (toward man and God). In the canon, Proverbs anchors Job’s pursuit of a mediator into God’s promises to the house of David.
Furthermore, a great place of prominence must be attributed to Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. within the Wisdom literature of the Hebrew Bible. It offers the answer to Job’s pursuit: God’s firstborn Son, God’s eternal wisdom, is the mediator between God and men.
The book of Proverbs displays certain compositional features essential for interpretation. Sailhamer divides the book into four major sections: Title (1:1), Prologue (chaps. 1–9), Body of the Book (chaps. 10–24; 25–29), and Conclusion (chaps. 30:1-33; 31:1-9; 31:10-31).17
Brevard Childs calls attention to two important passages in the final composition of the book: Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. and 30:5-6. Childs calls chap. 8 “the most striking development of the ‘self-revelation’ of wisdom (cf. Job 28; Sir 24)…. [I]ts hermeneutical effect for interpreting the whole book is worth exploring.”18
Childs further suggests that Prv 30:5-6Every word of God is fire tried: he is a buckler to them that hope in him., a passage rich with intertextual references, many of which are directly related to the coming Messiah,19 serves to ground wisdom theology into Israel’s Sacred Scripture.20 If Childs has correctly identified Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. and 30:5-6 as holding a place of prominence in the book, then 30:4 is all the more striking, for this verse binds Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. and 30:56 together.
Here, the hypostasis of Wisdom (chap. 8) is firmly rooted within the framework of God’s promises contained in the Sacred Scripture. “Who has ascended into heaven and descended? Who has gathered the wind in His fists? Who has wrapped the waters in His garment? Who has established all the ends of the earth? What is His name or His [S]on’s name? Surely you know!”21
This verse, according to Sailhamer, is an intentional allusion to Prv 8:27-30When he prepared the heavens, I was present: when with a certain law, and compass, he enclosed the depths:, for the purpose of “raising the question of the identity of the One who is with God and who brings wisdom from God to the human race.”22 The answer is provided by the author: it is God’s Son, the promised Messiah.
AN EXPOSITION OF PROVERBS 8:22-31
Proverbs 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. may be divided into two stanzas. Verses 22-26 emphasize the supernatural nature of Wisdom and vv. 27-31 highlight the participation of Wisdom in the creation of the world.
Several features of the Hebrew text suggest that reshit should be translated, not temporally (“the beginning”), but as a reference to the firstborn Son. First, several words are used in the Hebrew text, all of which suggest “birth” or “begetting” language.23 For instance, though kanah is used synonymously with the verb “create” in certain places (see Gn 14:19Blessed him, and said: Blessed be Abram by the most high God, who created heaven and earth., 22), it first occurs in Gn 4:1And Adam knew Eve his wife; who conceived and brought forth Cain, saying: I have gotten a man through God., referring to birth.
The abundance of lexical connections linking Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. with the early chapters of Genesis likely forms the backdrop for interpreting kanah in v. 22. Genesis 4:1And Adam knew Eve his wife; who conceived and brought forth Cain, saying: I have gotten a man through God. reads: “I have begotten (kanah) a man with the LORD” (author translation). This verse appears to mirror Prv 8:22The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning..24
In addition to the use of kanah, several other “begetting” words are also used in this passage. In vv. 24-25, the author uses the word cholal, “to bring forth, to travail [in childbirth]” (see Isa 51:2Look unto Abraham your father, and to Sara that bore you: for I called him alone, and blessed him, and multiplied him.; Job 39:1Knowest thou the time when the wild goats bring forth among the rocks, or hast thou observed the hinds when they fawn?; Dt 32:18Thou hast forsaken the God that begot thee, and hast forgotten the Lord that created thee.). Another word that resonates with “child” imagery is sha‘ashuim (“delight;” vv. 30, 31).
This word is used seven times in the Hebrew Bible, not counting the two references in Prv 8:30-31I was with him forming all things: and was delighted every day, playing before him at all times;; five times for the Torah (see Pss 119:24For thy testimonies are my meditation: and thy justifications my counsel., 77, 92, 143, 174), and twice for Israel as God’s delight (Isa 5:7For the vineyard of the Lord of hosts is the house of Israel: and the man of Juda, his pleasant plant: and I looked that he should do judgment, and behold iniquity: and do justice, and behold a cry.; Jer 31:20Surely Ephraim is an honourable son to me, surely he is a tender child: for since I spoke of him, I will still remember him. Therefore are my bowels troubled for him: pitying I will pity him, saith the Lord.). Particularly helpful is the reference in Jer 31:20Surely Ephraim is an honourable son to me, surely he is a tender child: for since I spoke of him, I will still remember him. Therefore are my bowels troubled for him: pitying I will pity him, saith the Lord.: “Isn’t Ephraim a precious son to Me, a delightful child?” This reference to a “delightful child” in Jeremiah may shed light on the enigmatic ’amon in v. 30.
Though this is translated as “master workman” or “craftsman” in the HCSB, NASB, ESV, NIV, and NKJV, Harmut Gese convincingly argues for another translation: “a child sitting on the lap.” He writes:
The frequently discussed question of the meaning of ’mon in v. 30 seems to me to be answered best with the basic signification of the root ’mn (qal): “to hold on one’s lap.” God is imaged here as sitting on a throne in the act of creation while wisdom seated on his lap, as his child, shares the royal position (cf. wisdom as companion, Sap. 9:4), even the masculine form is explained in this explanation because it avoids an otherwise obscene idea. 25
Gese’s explanation is consistent with the other “begetting” words in the passage. For the reasons mentioned above, and considering the innertextual connection to Prv 30:4Who hath ascended up into heaven, and descended? who hath held the wind in his hands? who hath bound up the waters together as in a garment? who hath raised up all the borders of the earth? what is his name, and what is the name of his…, a likely translation of Prv 8:22The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. is: “The Lord has begotten me, the firstborn [Son] of his ways.”
It is also worth noting that the word nisachti (“I was established” NASB) in v. 23 is used in only one other place in the Hebrew Bible, Ps 2:6But I am appointed king by him over Sion, his holy mountain, preaching his commandment.: “I have installed (nisach) my king upon Zion, my holy mountain.” The JPS retains this royal imagery: “From the distant past I was enthroned.”26
An important question any exposition of Prv 8 must tackle is whether or not Wisdom is created or eternal. To answer this question, it is important to keep the following in mind: (1) the LXX wrongly rendered kanah as “create,” rather than “beget,” causing the Church fathers a terrible, but unnecessary, headache; (2) this passage is a poetic interpretation of the creation account; poetic imagery must never be pressed too far; and (3) Wisdom exists, here, before creation.
With respect to this third point, Franz Delitzsch writes,
“[S]ince to her (wisdom) the poet attributes an existence preceding the creation of the world, he thereby declares her to be eternal, for to be before the world is to be before time.”27
Finally, as Athanasius pointed out, it is inconceivable to think of a time when God was without His Logos or Wisdom.28 For these reasons, Prv 8:22-26The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. must not be understood as the creation of Wisdom at a point in time. Rather, because Wisdom precedes creation, it must be regarded as uncreated, and, as a consequence, eternal.29
The second stanza (vv. 27-31) emphasizes Wisdom’s unique relationship with God. Although these verses do not clearly spell out Wisdom’s active participation with God in creation, information provided in Prv 3:19The Lord by wisdom hath founded the earth, hath established the heavens by prudence. by implication informs this conclusion.
The primary point of this passage, however, is not Wisdom’s instrumental role in creation. Rather the emphasis lies in the joyous exchange between Father and Son in the process of creation.
In v. 30, Wisdom is portrayed as a child sitting in His Father’s lap, laughing, playing, and bringing rapturous delight to his Father’s heart throughout the creation event. One cannot but think of v. 18 in John’s Prologue (“in the bosom of the Father” HCSB footnote) where, as Gese writes, “there appears the description of wisdom on God’s lap, the ’mun, known from Prov. 8:30I was with him forming all things: and was delighted every day, playing before him at all times;.”30
The conclusion of this passage (v. 30) holds profound implications for those willing to heed Wisdom’s invitation (Prv 8:1-4Doth not wisdom cry aloud, and prudence put forth her voice?). Not only does Wisdom bring joy to the Father’s heart, but for those who heed the call, Wisdom can bring divine delight to the sons of men (v. 31). The good news is staggering: by virtue of God’s Wisdom, the sons of men may participate in the delight of God!
CONCLUSION
Proverbs 8 provides a glimpse of the Father and His Son behind the veil of man’s finite experience. It celebrates the Father and the Son prior to, and throughout, the creation jubilee. This passage has played a formative role in both Jewish and Christian theology.
It was foundational to a reading of the creation narrative as something much more than a solo sung by a lonely, apathetic God. Rather, God sang the creation song in Triune harmony, His Son laughing, dancing, and playing in His lap as each day unfolded.
Although a Christological reading of Prv 8:22-31The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning. has fallen on hard times of late, Targum Neophyti and the Church fathers correctly understood Prv 8 as a reference to the Son of God, the promised Messiah. Treier rightly says that the Christological reading “does not finally complicate the interpretation of Prov. 8 but presents instead the resolution of a mystery latent in the text.”31
This key passage points the way to participation in the Father’s delight for any genuine seeker of God. Those who desire to enter into this joy are invited, provided they can each answer just one simple question: “What is the name of His Son? Surely you know” (Prv 30:4Who hath ascended up into heaven, and descended? who hath held the wind in his hands? who hath bound up the waters together as in a garment? who hath raised up all the borders of the earth? what is his name, and what is the name of his…).32
FURTHER READING
PROVERBS 30:4: THE INCOMPREHENSIBLE SON
Was Jesus a created being after all?
1. Bruce Waltke, The Book of Proverbs: Chapters 1–15, New International Commentary on the Old Testament, vol. 1 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004), n. 104, 409.
2. “Beginning” being understood as a reference to the undefined length of time in which God created the universe. See John Sailhamer, Genesis Unbound (Sisters, OR: Multnomah, 1999).
3. See reshit (v. 22; Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.); shamayim (v. 27; Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.); ’aretz (vv. 23, 26, 29, 31; Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth., 2, 11, 12, 15, 17, 20, 24, 25, 26, 28, 29, 30); ‘al pney tehom (v. 27; Gn 1:2And the earth was void and empty, and darkness was upon the face of the deep; and the spirit of God moved over the waters.a); tehom (vv. 24, 27; Gn 1:2And the earth was void and empty, and darkness was upon the face of the deep; and the spirit of God moved over the waters.); mayim (vv. 24, 29; Gn 1:2And the earth was void and empty, and darkness was upon the face of the deep; and the spirit of God moved over the waters.); yom (v. 30; Gn 1:5And he called the light Day, and the darkness Night; and there was evening and morning one day.); `asah (v. 26; Gn 1:7And God made a firmament, and divided the waters that were under the firmament, from those that were above the firmament, and it was so.); yam (v. 29; Gn 1:10And God called the dry land, Earth; and the gathering together of the waters, he called Seas. And God saw that it was good.); ‘adam (v. 31; Gn 1:26And he said: Let us make man to our image and likeness: and let him have dominion over the fishes of the sea, and the fowls of the air, and the beasts, and the whole earth, and every creeping creature that moveth upon the earth.); terem (v. 25; Gn 2:5And every plant of the field before it sprung up in the earth, and every herb of the ground before it grew: for the Lord God had not rained upon the earth; and there was not a man to till the earth.); `afar (v. 26; Gn 2:7And the Lord God formed man of the slime of the earth: and breathed into his face the breath of life, and man became a living soul.; 3:14, 19); kedem (v. 22; Gn 2:8And the Lord God had planted a paradise of pleasure from the beginning: wherein he placed man whom he had formed.). See also ma`yan (v. 24; Gn 7:11In the six hundredth year of the life of Noe, in the second month, in the seventeenth day of the month, all the fountains of the great deep were broken up, and the floodgates of heaven were opened:; 8:2); kanah (v. 22; Gn 4:1And Adam knew Eve his wife; who conceived and brought forth Cain, saying: I have gotten a man through God.; 14:19, 22; Dt 32:6Is this the return thou makest to the Lord, O foolish and senseless people? Is not he thy father, that hath possessed thee, and made thee, and created thee?; Ps 139:13For thou hast possessed my reins: thou hast protected me from my mother's womb.).
4. Miqraoth Gedoloth, vol. 1 (Tel Aviv: Pardes, 1957).
5. See, for example, Ps 33:6By the word of the Lord the heavens were established; and all the power of them by the spirit of his mouth:, Prv 3:19The Lord by wisdom hath founded the earth, hath established the heavens by prudence., and Job 28.
6. John Sailhamer cogently argues that the Pentateuch is a wisdom composition. See “A Wisdom Composition of the Pentateuch?” in The Way of Wisdom: Essays in Honor of Bruce K. Waltke, ed. J. I. Packer and Sven K. Soderlund, 15–35 (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2000).
7. Some have suggested that “the Son of God” was a Christian gloss, but a careful look at the actual manuscript of TN proves this to be untenable. The spacing in the verse reveals (1) the da (“of”) is original; (2) the wa (“and”) was obviously a gloss that was later erased because it was not original.
8. Alejandro Díez Macho, Neophyti 1: Targum Palestinense MS de la Biblioteca Vaticana, Tomo I, Génesis (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientícas, 1968), 3 (emphasis added).
9. On the literary qualities of Gn 1:1In the beginning God created heaven, and earth. see Gordon Wenham, Genesis 1–15, Word Biblical Commentary, vol. 1 (Waco, TX: Word Books, 1987), 6; Shimon BarEfrat, Narrative Art in the Bible (Sheffield, England: Sheffield Academic Press, 1984), 203; and John Sailhamer, Genesis, Expositor’s Bible Commentary, vol. 2 (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1990), 35.
10. See Rashi’s comments in Miqraoth Gedoloth.
11. Miqraoth Gedoloth (words in brackets provided).
12. See J. Robert Wright, ed., Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Solomon, Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture: Old Testament, vol. 9 (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2005), 59–71.
13. Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 1–9, Anchor Yale Bible Commentaries, vol. 18a (Doubleday: New York, 2000), 279…
17. Ibid., 350.
18. Brevard Childs, Introduction to the Old Testament as Scripture (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1979), 554.
19. Several key messianic passages are quoted and/or alluded to in vv. 1-6, including Dt 30:12-13Nor is it in heaven, that thou shouldst say: Which of us can go up to heaven to bring it unto us, and we may hear and fulfil it in work?; Nm 24:3-9He took up his parable and said: Balaam the son of Beor hath said: The man hath said, whose eye is stopped up:; 2Sm 23:1-7Now these are David's last words. David the son of Isai said: The man to whom it was appointed concerning the Christ of the God of Jacob, the excellent psalmist of Israel said:; and Ps 18:50Therefore will I give glory to thee, O Lord, among the nations, and I will sing a psalm to thy name.. See Bruce K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs: Chapters 16–31, New International Commentary on the Old Testament, vol. 2 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2005), 474.
20. Childs, 556–57.
21. Prv 30:4Who hath ascended up into heaven, and descended? who hath held the wind in his hands? who hath bound up the waters together as in a garment? who hath raised up all the borders of the earth? what is his name, and what is the name of his… NASB (capitalization provided).
22. Sailhamer, NIV Compact Commentary, 354.
23. See Richard J. Clifford, Proverbs: A Commentary (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 1999), 96.
24. “I have begotten a man, the LORD” mirrors Prv 8:22The Lord possessed me in the beginning of his ways, before he made any thing from the beginning.: “The LORD has begotten me” (author translation).
25. Hartmut Gese, “Wisdom, Son of Man, and the Origins of Christology: The Consistent Development of Biblical Theology,” Horizons in Biblical Theology 3 (1981): 31.
26. Complete Tanach with Rashi software (Brooklyn: Judaica Press, Davka Corporation, 1999).
27. C. F. Keil and F. Delitzsch, Pentateuch, Commentary on the Old Testament, vol. 1 (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1996), 133. The phrase “before time,” is considered by some to be philosophically problematic. Perhaps a better expression might be, “before the existence of any created thing.”
28. Athanasius, “Four Discourses Against the Arians,” Discourse 1.24, Athanasius: Selected Works and Letters, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4, ed. Philip Schaff and Henry Wace (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 2004), 320.
29. See the exposition and theological evaluation by Daniel J. Treier, Proverbs and Ecclesiastes Brazos Theological Commentary on the Bible (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2011), 44–57. Treier notes that those who argue for the language of creation see wisdom as created. This is also problematic since wisdom is part of the attributes of God and must necessarily be part of His eternal being (p. 49).
30. Gese, “Wisdom, Son of Man, and the Origins of Christology,” 54.
31. Daniel J. Treier, Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, 51.
32. Author’s translation.